BT In A New Key
A blog for people who seek alternative approaches to kiruv and the baal teshuvah experience.
Friday, March 27, 2026
Maybe be the camel
After being rescued from a petting zoo, a special camel had trouble fitting in with the other animals on the rescue farm. It wanted nothing more than to be friends with all the horses and alpacas, but they had never seen a camel before. After a while, they realized that it was just a funny version of them, so they began to warm up to it, and now it has become part of the herd
https://x.com/i/status/2037152600051617848
Thursday, March 26, 2026
cooler heads
Some rabbis are so out of touch with the concerns of people that it is appalling. I once attended a talk given to a Carlebach minyan where a visiting rabbi told a room of music lovers that listening to music has been forbidden since the destruction of the Temple, except for zmiros at Shabbos tables and some music at weddings. Rabbi Shlomo Carelbach was a talented songwriter and performer who built an entire kiruv track based largely on music. People who follow his derech connect to Judaism largely through music. I do not know what this rabbi was trying to accomplish with his presentation, but he certainly risked pushing people away from Torah observance. I know this rabbi to be a gentleman, but he was trained to impose Judaism like a straight jacket. Incredibly, he is Modern Orthodox and is associated with Yeshiva University, but many rabbis in the Modern Orthodox world have taken on sensibilities of other groups even though they are paid by Modern Orthodox people.
But cooler heads can prevail. One BT who was an aficionado of opera was most upset to hear that halacha prohibited him from attending operas because he'd hear women singing. The rabbi who gave him this news eventually took him to a prominent posek who told him if I recall correctly that attending operas would be permitted to him if his interest was in the entire spectacle, not just the women singing. After the young man left the room, the posek took the rabbi aside and chastised him, saying that he should know better than to pass on such restrictions without checking for a leniency.
Friday, March 20, 2026
The fraudulence of Western Society
The government forces you to go to public school where you are brainwashed on the alleged sanctity of college. The colleges charge more money than the price of a house but claim to give "financial aid" to 80% of students. Turns out the 80% of that aid is loans upon which one cannot default. They work like this;
And then in college, there's hardly a major that leads to earning income. It's mostly musical theater, literature, philosophy, biology, etc.
Now, one reason her interest is so high is because she probably pays less than the full amount each month. But that could be in part because she couldn't find a job.
Tuesday, March 17, 2026
Monday, March 16, 2026
when you're done with the yeshiva world
A bear, forced to live in appalling conditions in a tiny cage at a honey farm for years, is rescued, and while playing in a pool at the sanctuary, it realizes that it is truly free...
https://x.com/i/status/2033443327740416471
Friday, March 13, 2026
Don't be so quick to judge
A man shared this with me:
I used to go once a year to baseball games. I had several reasons for sitting in the upper deck of baseball games that I would attend once a year in New York. Firstly, it put some distance between me and the gentiles who attended games. Often they drank or sat with their shirts off. They cursed. In the upper deck I could sit 100 feet away and be spared most of that. I worked this out with a rabbi, that this was a middle ground between never attending, which was a bit problematic since I grew up on baseball, and mingling more than was necessary. Secondly, I enjoyed the view of the grass. It felt like sitting in the mountains, which I never had occasion to do in the city. Thirdly, there's a breeze up there, and I usually attended in July when it's hot and humid in New York. Fourthly, I could watch the whole field and observe the full dimension of the game. Lastly, you don't have to worry about batted balls up there. People do get hit by balls. A Jewish women was killed by a ball in Los Angeles a few years back and a little girl suffered permanent brain damage at a different game recently. I study Torah for more than half the game, and in the upper deck I'm not distracted by concern of batted balls. This last reason wasn't the main reason. It was one of the reasons. Rav Avigdor Miller, who is one of my influences, emphasized that a person should exercise caution in matters of physical safety. He talked about this often. I was honoring his teaching. not only that but upper deck seats are $25 and mezzanine seats are $125. To me spending $125 for a baseball game is not justifiable. I could buy a sefer. I could give tzedukah. I could keep it in the bank. The players don't need to make $10,000,000 a year and if fans would refuse to pay ridiculously high prices, the inflated salaries would come down. All kinds of reasons go into the decision.