What actor or actress passed on a script that could have made them a powerhouse in Hollywood?
James Caan, who recently died at 82, had a bad habit of turning down roles that made others a star, often earning them an Oscar or an Oscar nomination.
For instance, he turned down 3 roles that Richard Dreyfuss took, including “Close Encounter of the Third Kind,” “The Good Bye Girl,” and “What About Bob?” He also passed on the Oscar-winning role that earned Jack Nicholson an Oscar in “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.” Another such role was Dustin Hoffman’s lead in “Kramer versus Kramer.”
Caan was originally considered to play Michael Corleone (the studio wanted him or Robert Redford) but ultimately moved to the Sonny Corleone role. Other roles that it was said that Jimmy Caan did not get were the role of Han Solo in “Star Wars.” Caan was asked about appearing in “Apocalypse Now” only to have his agent say he would do so only if they paid him $1 million to read the script. That role—-a small one—then went to Harrison Ford.
When Jimmy Caan was offered the lead role in “Misery,” he took it because Jack Nicholson had just turned it down, and he remembered the previous mis-step in not taking “One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.” I cover more on Jimmy Caan’s uncanny ability to shoot his undeniable acting prowess in the foot on my WeeklyWilson blog.
Caan was born on March 26, 1940, in The Bronx, New York City, to Sophie (née Falkenstein; 1915–2016)[3] and Arthur Caan (1909–1986), Jewish immigrants from Bingen am Rhein, Rhineland, Germany.[4][5][6] His father was a kosher meat dealer.[7]